Opagio vs Pulley: Cap Table and the Layer Above
Opagio vs Pulley — how the two platforms fit together. Pulley runs cap table, 409A and equity admin; Opagio measures the intangible value behind it.
Introduction
Founders looking at Opagio and Pulley are usually shortlisting two tools that do different jobs. Pulley is a cap table and 409A platform — a younger, well-regarded challenger to Carta in the US equity-admin market, positioned as affordable and transparent on pricing. Opagio is an intangible asset platform — twelve value drivers, asset-level valuation, lending readiness, and exit-preparation in a continuous platform model.
The two are not in competition. They sit on different layers of the same company. Pulley manages who owns what; Opagio measures what those shares are actually worth and why. For most growth-stage companies, the right operating model is to run both alongside each other.
This page lays out what each platform does well, where the layers connect, and the specific scenarios where one or both belong in the stack.
TL;DR: Choose Pulley for cap table management, 409A valuations, equity plan administration, and scenario modelling — Pulley is a well-regarded Carta challenger with a transparent fixed-per-stakeholder pricing model. Choose Opagio for intangible asset valuation, lending readiness, exit preparation, and ongoing growth measurement across Opagio 12™. Most growth-stage businesses benefit from running both: Pulley for the equity layer, Opagio for the intangible value layer behind it.
About Pulley
Pulley is a US-headquartered cap table and equity administration platform, positioned as an affordable, transparent alternative to Carta in the same broad market. Founded with the explicit objective of being simpler and more predictably priced than the incumbent, Pulley has built a credible product suite covering:
- Cap table management — issuance, transfers, vesting schedules, classes-and-series tracking
- 409A valuations — IRS-compliant share valuations for US-incorporated startups granting employee options
- Equity plan administration — option grants, RSUs, employee equity portals
- Scenario modelling — round modelling, dilution analysis, waterfall outcomes
- Fixed-price subscription — fixed price per stakeholder, no hidden fees; positioned as more predictable than the incumbent's tiered scaling model
Pulley's institutional credibility runs through its customer base in the US startup ecosystem and its positioning as a transparent, founder-friendly alternative. Pricing is publicly indicated as starting from $1,200 per year for early-stage companies, scaling with stakeholder count.
For the founder or CFO of a US-incorporated startup looking for a credible cap table platform with a simpler pricing model than the dominant incumbent, Pulley is a serious option.
All facts in this section are taken from Pulley's public materials. Pricing details and feature availability vary by plan and jurisdiction; buyers should consult Pulley directly for current details.
About Opagio
Opagio is a UK-headquartered intangible asset platform organised around Opagio 12™ — a proprietary taxonomy of twelve value drivers covering customer capital, organisational capital, brand and reputation, human capital, technology, data, supplier and partnership capital, design and aesthetic capital, financial structure, regulatory and IP capital, sustainability and ESG capital, and innovation pipeline. Within those twelve drivers sits a comprehensive library of intangible asset types — the assets that drive most of the enterprise value of modern businesses but rarely appear on a conventional balance sheet.
Opagio is delivered as a SaaS platform with two paid products and one free tier:
- Opagio Growth Forecaster (free) — accessible scoring of intangible exposure for a single company
- Opagio Growth Forecaster Pro — paid Explore-zone product layering benchmark and competitive context
- Opagio Intangibles (paid platform) — the full discovery, valuation, and management environment, with modules including the Asset Valuator (Relief from Royalty, Multi-Period Excess Earnings, With and Without, Cost, DCF, and trading-comparable methods), Growth Plan, Value Drivers Register™, Normalised P&L, Intelligence, and Growth Accounting
Opagio's Asset Valuator output is structured for IFRS 3 / IAS 38 (UK and global) and ASC 805 / ASC 350 (US) alignment.
Pulley tells you who owns what — cap table, 409A, equity admin. Opagio tells you what those shares represent claims against — twelve value drivers, asset-level valuation, growth tracking. Different jobs, different layers, complementary stack.
Side-by-Side Comparison
The table below sets out the buyer view across the criteria that come up most often when founders are scoping their stack.
Side-by-side criteria
| Criterion | Opagio | Pulley |
|---|---|---|
| Primary job | Intangible asset valuation and growth measurement | Cap table, equity administration, 409A valuations |
| Unit of analysis | The individual intangible asset (customer capital, technology, brand, etc.) | The equity holding (shares, options, RSUs, SAFEs) |
| Valuation methodology | Asset Valuator: RFR, MPEEM, With and Without, Cost, DCF, market multiples — IFRS 3 / IAS 38 / ASC 805 aligned | 409A — IRS-compliant share valuation for US option-granting startups |
| Taxonomy | The Opagio 12™ — twelve value drivers with a comprehensive library of asset types | Equity instrument types (common, preferred, options, RSUs, SAFEs, warrants) |
| Time horizon | Continuous platform — assets and values tracked month-on-month | Continuous platform — equity events recorded as they happen; 409A refreshed annually or on material change |
| Capital pathway coverage | Four pathways: borrow (IP-backed lending), protect, fundraise, exit | Fundraise (round modelling); equity-driven exit waterfall |
| Output for the founder | Value Drivers Register, Asset Valuator reports, Normalised P&L, Lending Readiness Report | Cap table, 409A valuation, equity grants, option plan |
| Output for the investor / acquirer | Asset-level intangible value picture, growth-driver narrative, IFRS / US GAAP-aligned valuation | Cap table walk-through, fully diluted ownership, waterfall outcomes |
| Jurisdictional scope | UK-primary, multi-jurisdiction roadmap (US, Canada, Australia, Ireland) | US-anchored, US-incorporated startups primary use case |
| Pricing model (qualitative) | Tiered SaaS subscription — free Forecaster, paid Forecaster Pro, paid Opagio Intangibles platform | Fixed price per stakeholder, transparent SaaS pricing |
| Best fit when… | The buyer needs a structured view across the full intangible base — for fundraising narrative, lending, exit prep, ongoing growth tracking | The buyer needs cap table management and an IRS-compliant 409A with a transparent pricing model |
How the two platforms fit together
Example — Where Opagio is the better fit: A B2B SaaS founder is 18 months out from a Series B and preparing the value-driver narrative the investor will want. The cap table is clean (Pulley handles it). But the investor's question — "what are you building, and why is the next round worth what you think it's worth" — sits in the intangible base: customer capital (NRR, churn cohorts), technology, organisational capital, the team, and the brand. Opagio's twelve-driver platform tracks all of that continuously and produces the structured narrative the investor expects. The work Opagio does is upstream of the cap table.
Example — Where Pulley is the better fit: A US-incorporated seed-stage startup has closed a $2.5M priced round, hired six engineers, and needs to issue stock options. The immediate job is the cap table, vesting schedules, option grant agreements, and an IRS-compliant 409A so the strike price is defensible. Pulley is purpose-built for that workflow with a transparent per-stakeholder pricing model that doesn't surprise the founder as the team grows. For this job, Opagio is not the answer; it sits one layer up.
Pulley runs the equity layer of the company. Opagio runs the intangible-asset layer behind the equity. For most growth-stage companies, the right operating model is to run both — Pulley for cap table and 409A, Opagio for the value-driver narrative that explains why those shares are worth what they're worth.
When You Need Pulley
Pulley is a good fit when:
- You are a US-incorporated startup granting stock options and need an IRS-compliant 409A
- You have a growing cap table (10+ stakeholders) and want a system of record with predictable pricing
- You want a transparent fixed-per-stakeholder subscription rather than a tiered model that surprises you as the team scales
- Your equity admin needs employee-facing tools (option grant acceptance, vesting visibility, equity portals)
- You are early enough in your build that the cap table and 409A are the most pressing job
For UK companies, Pulley's US-anchored product surface and US-incorporated user base are worth understanding before committing — the equivalent UK equity admin market has SeedLegals, Capdesk, Ledgy, and Carta UK as the dominant choices.
When You Need Opagio
Opagio is a good fit when:
- You are preparing investor material for a fundraising round and the conversation has shifted from "who owns what" to "what are you building and why is it worth this much"
- You are 12-36 months out from a potential exit and want to start building the intangible-value narrative the acquirer's diligence team will probe
- You are scoping an IP-backed lending facility and need a Lending Readiness Report
- You are a PE or VC fund tracking the intangible value of investee companies across the portfolio
- Your business depends materially on customer capital, organisational capital, human capital, or data assets
- You need a CFO-grade view of intangible value that refreshes month-on-month, not annually
Note (jurisdiction): Pulley's 409A is a US-specific IRS construct. Opagio's Asset Valuator covers IFRS 3 / IAS 38 (UK and global) and ASC 805 / ASC 350 (US). The two outputs are not interchangeable — a 409A is a share-level valuation for IRS purposes; an Asset Valuator output is an asset-level intangible valuation for financial reporting, fundraising, lending, and exit purposes.
Where the Two Platforms Touch (and Where They Don't)
The narrow overlap between the two platforms sits at the point of share valuation. Pulley produces a 409A; Opagio produces an asset-level intangible valuation that sits behind any share-price story. These are not the same valuation, and they answer different questions for different counterparties:
- A 409A is a share-level IRS-compliant fair market value, used to set the strike price of employee options. Calculated by a qualified appraiser using accepted methodologies and refreshed annually or on a material event.
- An Asset Valuator output is an asset-level intangible valuation, used to support fundraising narrative, IP-backed lending, exit preparation, and IFRS 3 / ASC 805-aligned financial reporting.
The two outputs sit alongside each other on the same company without overlap. For the founder, this means the right operating model is additive (Pulley + Opagio) rather than substitutive.
FAQ
Is Opagio a Pulley competitor?
Answer
No. Pulley is the cap table, 409A, and equity-admin platform. Opagio is the intangible asset platform — twelve value drivers, asset-level valuation, lending readiness, exit preparation. The two cover different layers of the same company. For most growth-stage businesses, the right operating model is to run both alongside each other.
Do I need Opagio if I already use Pulley?
Answer
It depends on the question you're trying to answer. If your immediate need is the cap table, 409A, and option admin, Pulley is sufficient. If your conversation has moved beyond ownership into "what are we building, and why is it worth what we think it is" — fundraising narrative, exit preparation, ongoing growth measurement, IP-backed lending — Opagio addresses a job Pulley does not.
Can Pulley value my intangible assets?
Answer
Pulley's 409A produces a share-level fair market value calculated by a qualified appraiser. It is not an asset-level intangible valuation — it does not produce a Relief from Royalty number for the brand, an MPEEM-derived value for customer relationships, or a Cost Approach figure for organisational capital. For asset-level intangible valuation aligned to IFRS 3 / IAS 38 / ASC 805, Opagio's Asset Valuator module is purpose-built.
Can Opagio replace my cap table?
Answer
No. Opagio does not manage equity issuance, vesting schedules, option grants, employee portals, or scenario waterfall modelling. For all of those, a dedicated cap table platform (Pulley, Carta, or one of the UK alternatives) is the right tool. Opagio sits one layer up.
Which platform should I buy first?
Answer
For a seed-stage US-incorporated startup with employee options and a growing cap table, Pulley (or an equivalent) typically comes first — the equity-admin job is the most immediately pressing. For a UK growth-stage business preparing investor material, an IP-backed lending application, or exit preparation, Opagio often comes first because the intangible-value story is what is needed in front of the counterparty.
Pulley vs Carta — does the choice of cap table platform affect Opagio?
Answer
No. Opagio sits one layer above the cap table and does not depend on which cap table platform you use. Whether you use Pulley, Carta, or one of the UK alternatives, Opagio Intangibles runs the same way. The integration is one-directional: cap table data and 409A outputs inform context, but Opagio does not write back into the cap table.
How does pricing compare?
Answer
Both platforms operate on tiered SaaS subscription models. Pulley publishes a fixed-per-stakeholder pricing model that scales with cap table size. Opagio publishes tiered pricing — a free Growth Forecaster, a paid Growth Forecaster Pro in the Explore zone, and a paid Opagio Intangibles platform subscription. Because the two platforms do different jobs, the question is rarely "either / or" on cost.
Where can I see Opagio in action?
Answer
Book a demo and we will walk through the Opagio 12™ taxonomy, the Asset Valuator module, and the platform's portfolio views with a worked example relevant to your use case. The demo is run by a member of the Opagio team and typically takes 30-40 minutes.
Closing
Pulley is a credible cap table and 409A platform with a transparent pricing model and a strong product surface for US-incorporated growth-stage startups. For the equity-administration job — ownership, 409A, option plans, scenario modelling — it is a serious choice.
Opagio is the platform-shaped fit for the layer above the cap table: the twelve-driver intangible asset taxonomy that explains what those shares actually represent claims against. For founders building fundraising narrative, CFOs running continuous intangible measurement, PE/VC funds tracking portfolio value creation, and businesses scoping IP-backed lending, Opagio is the structured answer to the question "what are we building, and why is it worth what we think it is".
The best way to know whether Opagio fits is to see it against a real scenario. Book a demo and bring a real context — a fundraising round, an exit window, a portfolio review, or a lending application.
Related reading
- Opagio vs Carta — Cap Table and Intangible Value Compared
- Carta alternative for valuation — when to add Opagio to your stack
- Opagio vs BizEquity — UK SME Business Valuation Compared
- Intangible asset glossary — Customer Relationships
- Intangible asset glossary — Relief from Royalty
- Intangible asset glossary — Multi-Period Excess Earnings
- IP-backed lending in the UK — eligibility, lenders, and the application process
Related Glossary Terms
Learn More
Ready to Value Your Intangible Assets?
Use Opagio's valuation tools to apply these methods to your own business.